ZAP vs Burpsuite in my mind at 2022
Hi :D
I'm going to compare ZAP and Burpsuite after a long time. Of course, it's extremely subjective, so I hope you light enjoy it.
##ย TL;DR
- ZAP has powerful scripting engine and automation
- Burpsuite has powerful scanning engine and Thatโs Early adopter.
- They're both really cool tools.
##ย Compare
| ZAP | Burpsuite | |
|---|---|---|
| Proxy | O , HTTP/1.1 | O๐ HTTP/1.1 , HTTP/2 |
| Paasive Scan | O | O |
| Active Scan | O | O |
| Scan Configuration | O๐, Easy, Detail control | O |
| Scan Results | O, Mapping more information | O, Detail results |
| Live Scan | O, ATTACK Mode | O, Live tasks |
| Manage scope | O, Detail | O, Easy |
| Manage workspace | O | O |
| Spidering | O, Spider, Ajax Spider | O, Powerful Crawler |
| Extensions (Addons) | O, High quality | O๐, High quality, Many features |
| Scripting | O๐, Zest ๐, Ruby, Python, JS, Groovy, Etc | O, Python, Ruby |
| Performance | O, Fast, but..., Heavy ๐ซ | O, More fast, but, Very heavy ๐คฏ |
| Automation | O๐, Automation framework, REST API, Cli flags | O, REST API (Pro), GraphQL API (Enterprise) |
| Friendly CI/CD | O๐, Github actions, Jenkins extensions, REST API, Cli flags, Automation framework | O, REST API (Pro), GraphQL API (Enterprise) |
| Dark mode | O Intellij theme is posiible, but it is not official support | O, Support Intelij theme |
| Embedded browser | O , Firefox , Chrome , PhantomJS , Gecko | O, Chrome , But, burpsuite is persistant to broswser session ๐ |
| Manual Testing | O , Manual Request , Requester , Only History | O๐ , Repeater , Inspector , Stepper , Logger, Flow and many history extensions |
| Fuzzing | O๐, with fuzz script | O๐ , with turbo intruder |
| OAST Testing | O๐ , OAST (public/private oast) , Callbacks (system oast) , Interactsh | O๐ , Burp collaborator (public/private oast) , Interactsh (extension) |
| AAA Testing | O , Access Control , Zest | O, Many extensions |
| DOM Testing | O, Eval Billian | O๐ , DOM Invador ๐ , When active scan for DOM, burp is powerful |
| Param Mining | O, Only with fuzzer, Powerful but not easy | O๐, Param Minor ๐, Powerful and easy |
| Smuggling Testing | O, Manual Request, Fuzzer | O๐, Repeater, Turbo Intruder, HTTP Smuggler |
| Utility for Testing | O , En/Decoder , Compare , Note , Etc.. | O , En/Decoder , Compare , Note , Etc.. |
| Statements | O, Statd, Scanning Graph | X |
| Support WebSocket | O | O |
| Support SSE | O | X |
| Support postMessage | O | O |
| Support JWT | O | O |
| Support GraphQL | O | O๐, inQL..! |
| New Tech | O | O๐, Fast apply |
| Using other applications | O | O |
| Customize | O๐ | O |
| HotKeys | O | O |
| Settings | O๐, Very detail control | O |
| Friendly User | O , Cool documents | O๐, Most people like Burp, Many articles |
| Dashboard | X | O |
| Use from web | O, Web Swing, HUD | X |
โ๏ธ UI
Choose the UI according to your feel! They are similar but very different. but I love both :D
โก๏ธ Power of ZAP
๐ชย Powerful Scripting
ZAP is based on a powerful scripting engine. Through this, I can configure everything I need for testing. which is the most powerful function of ZAP I think.
The more you script, the more the possibility and power of ZAP becomes.
โ๏ธย Configuration
ZAP supports very detailed configurations. This means that it's good for you to optimize the tool.
If you set it up well, it can't be more comfortable.
๐คย Automation
The direction ZAP pursues is in Automation. This is really good for CICD or automation flow beyond just tools for manual testing.
Imagine that a tool you know well is in automation. It's really cool, right?
๐งย Power of Burpsuite
๐ญย Powerful Scanning
As everyone knows, Burpsuite's scanner is the best scanning engine in existence. Based on portswigger's outstanding research, it is very detailed and proficient in catching new technologies.
However, from how I feel about using Burpsuite Enterprise, there are parts that are not enough to leave everything to testing.
๐จย Fast support new tech
As I said before, burpsuite is good at new technologies! This has great advantages not only for scanners but also for manual testing.
๐ฅย User frendly
Burpsuite is a tool loved by most security engineers and Burgbounty hunters. It has been the same for a long time and will probably be the same in the future.
Good communities and many materials can always be of great help, from beginners to experts. This is a really good weapon.
๐ฅ Me
I really like both, but I like ZAP more now :D